Image description: A close-up of Paul Ryan’s hands holding up a copy of the American Health Care Act with a red ‘NO’ mark (a circle with a line through it) superimposed on top. (Credit: Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund)
As a disability rights advocate and person who well remembers the palpable fear I felt for my family when we were uninsured and who has depended on Medicaid in the past, I’ve been following the development of the American Health Care Act (AHCA) closely.
I strongly oppose the AHCA. It is a Very Bad Thing. Even Trump has called it “mean.” Rand Paul called it a “deplorable” subsidy for insurance companies. The Congressional Budget Office projects that the AHCA would raise the uninsured rate by 23 million by 2026, leaving 18.6% of the US population uninsured.[1] The AHCA would gut Medicaid, the program that covers 1 in 5 USAmericans. The program that’s expanded coverage to more than 15 million people since the Affordable Care Act (ACA, aka ‘Obamacare’) was first implemented in 2013. A program that currently covers 45% of US births (on average, up to almost 70% in some states) and more than 10 million people with disabilities. The AHCA would also institute waivers that would allow insurance companies to significantly increase charges to older people and eliminate essential benefits like maternity and mental health care and prescription drugs.[2] It would usher in insurance caps that would limit the benefits a person could utilize in their lifetime. It would eliminate federal funding for Planned Parenthood, a lifeline for primary care and family planning for so many women, *especially* uninsured women.[3]
Health care is a human right. Without access to health care, people die. They get sick, not just from the lack of medical attention but from the stress of living a precarious existence and managing expensive–often ruinous–medical bills. If the AHCA passes, people will lose access to health care and services that keep them alive, in their homes, and active in their communities, that enable them to go to school and to work. People will lose quality care and face institutionalization and homelessness. People will die.
Protesting all this is Paul Ryan #Harlem pic.twitter.com/Wc3stxJKll
— Stacy Parker LeMelle (@StacyLeMelle) May 9, 2017
Image description: A Tweet dated 9 May 2017 from @StacyLeMelle shows a line of people against a wall holding signs that look like tombstones. They read: “RIP LOST MEDICAID NO $ FOR CARE,” “DEATH BY 1000 MEDICAID CUTS,” RIP DEATH BY SUICIDE LOST MENTAL HEALTH CARE,” “COULDN’T AFFORD ASTHMA CARE,” “RIP CHOSE RENT OVER MEDS,” and “RIP COULDN’T AFFORD THE COST OF BEING A WOMAN.” More protesters with signs extend beyond the left edge of the image.
So, yeah. I’ve been consuming and producing a fair amount of discourse about the AHCA lately. I’ve been calling my representatives and tweeting a lot about #AHCA. I’ve been reading lots of newspaper and web coverage. I’ve been seeking out and amplifying the voices of people with disabilities who share how this bill will affect them. While I’ve done a fair amount to express my own views and spread important perspectives in the debate [4], I feel like it’s not doing anything to slow the Existential Threat at hand. And while I’ve done a fair amount to educate myself about the AHCA, I’ve done so in a political echo chamber of my own curation. I haven’t sought out voices I don’t agree with.
I’ve been responding to a crisis, scrambling to learn as much as I can and struggling to process all that I’m learning along with the rage and heartbreak it brings on. And I’ve turned to stories and storytelling as a strategy both for education (mine and others) and for strength. Thing is, I don’t feel like anyone’s hearing the stories I’m sharing and telling but me and the folks who agree with me.
I keep thinking about this Twitter thread from David M. Perry:
2) We're telling stories about ourselves, our families, the numbers, the law, the principles. Because all the facts say #SaveMedicaid
— David M. Perry (@Lollardfish) June 20, 2017
4) I don't think we can save Medicaid with the facts on Medicaid. We can only save it by making the intended thievery visible. Maybe.
— David M. Perry (@Lollardfish) June 20, 2017
Stories aren’t working. Maybe “making the intended thievery visible” will. Anyway, I don’t understand how anyone could justify this Very Bad Thing. Maybe I could at least make the intended thievery and the strategies used to facilitate said thievery visible to me.
As a critical discourse analyst, I’ve always appreciated how using CDA [5] gives me the analytical distance to face Very Bad Things that fill me with rage, that break my heart, that–were it not for my communication studies lens–I would not be able to look at. Doing CDA brackets my gut-wrenching emotional reaction for a time so I’m able to examine the Very Bad Thing closely and from multiple angles. I still sometimes break down and weep or jump out of my chair to pace and scream in the midst of working. But afterwards I can get back to it.
So, I’m starting a new and rather urgent research program: studying #AHCA discourse on the right, paying particular attention to arguments in favor of the AHCA. I’ve identified some common framing–e.g., “repeal and replace”–that I’m gathering data on. I’ve collected some key texts that I think warrant in-depth analyses of their own. And I’ve only started to follow the money, but I’ll be working to better understand who benefits from the GOP’s health care plan and what’s being said about/by them.
I’ll publish my findings on this blog. Here’s to making thievery visible. Let’s hope it makes a difference.
[1] The uninsured rate hasn’t been over 17% since the 1990s. By comparison, if we stay with ‘Obamacare,’ it’s estimated that 10% of US residents will be uninsured in 2026. The uninsured rate has dramatically and steadily dropped since the ACA Marketplace first opened in 2013.
[2] The original House version of the bill would have allowed insurance companies to charge more or deny coverage to people with pre-existing conditions. As I write, the Washington Post is reporting that a leaked draft of the Senate’s version retains “ACA protections for patients with preexisting conditions.” However, Andy Slavitt at USA Today reports that loopholes would maintain ‘protections’ but allow insurers to decline to pay for particular treatments.
[3] When I was uninsured, Planned Parenthood provided the only primary care I could access and afford. And it was quality, compassionate primary care.
[4] While I call contemporary discourse about the AHCA a ‘debate,’ I should also stress that it is an unusual one, given the unprecedented silence on the part of the people drafting the bill.
[5] I’ll explain CDA more in my next post. In a nutshell, critical discourse analysis or CDA is a method for studying the ways in which communication-in-use supports or undermines social injustice.
Excellent data. Thanks a lot!
http://talahicc.com/
prescription online
london drugs canada
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacies-24h
Useful advice. Thanks.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
pharmacy online store northwest pharmacy canada drug northwestpharmacy
mexican pharmacies
online drugs
canadian pharmacies that are legit
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
walmart pharmacy price check
online prescription drugs
You expressed this exceptionally well!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
mexican pharmacies canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacies top best canadian pharmacy online
mail order pharmacies
pharmacies near me
price prescription drugs
cheap drugs online
rx online
prescription drugs canada
Amazing content. Many thanks.
https://nicktambone.com/
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies global pharmacy canada northwest pharmacy canada canada pharmaceutical online ordering
canadian rx pharmacy online
discount pharmaceuticals
discount drugs online pharmacy
pharmacy online mexico
compare rx prices
canada pharmacy no prescription
You suggested this adequately.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
rx price comparison aarp approved canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs without doctor approval canadian pharcharmy
best online pharmacy stores
pharmacies near me
pharmacy tech
canada drug prices
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
medical information online
Reliable advice. Kudos!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
online pharmacy usa canada online pharmacies canadian drug store canadian pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
canada drugs online
mexican pharmacy online medications
canadian meds
walmart pharmacy price check
global pharmacy canada
Very good write ups. Kudos.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadapharmacyonline com northwestpharmacy no prescription pharmacy london drugs canada
canadian pharmacy meds
canadian pharmacy reviews
canadian drugstore online
prescription drugs without doctor approval
prescription prices comparison
canada pharmacy online no script
Wonderful forum posts. Many thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharmacy online canada online pharmacies of canada canadian pharmacy king canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that are legit
best online pharmacies canada
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian pharmacies online
walgreens pharmacy
canadian mail order pharmacies
This is nicely expressed! .
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
drugstore online canadian pharmacy pain meds online without doctor prescription online pharmacies canada
online rx pharmacy
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
board of pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
Thanks, Valuable information.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
online drugs canadian pharmaceuticals online online canadian discount pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online
canadian pharmacy meds
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
online discount pharmacy
best online pharmacy
no prescription online pharmacy
canada pharmacy online no script
Good posts. Regards!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian prescription drugstore canadian viagra best online pharmacy mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canada pharmacy no prescription
costco pharmacy pricing
online canadian pharmacies
buy drugs online
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
highest rated canadian pharmacies
Thanks. Ample information.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
compare rx prices london drugs canada canadadrugs.com pharmacy canadian viagra
best online pharmacy stores
canada pharmacies
prescription online
canada drugs online
pharmacies near me
pharmacy price compare
Thanks. Excellent information!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadianpharmacy online pharmacies of canada no prior prescription required pharmacy canadian pharcharmy
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian drugstore reviews
drug costs
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
cheap drugs online
best online international pharmacies
You actually mentioned it very well!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
mexican pharmacies canada pharmaceutical online ordering canadian drugstore canada pharmacy online
best online canadian pharcharmy
canadian rx pharmacy online
buy prescription drugs online
cheap prescription drugs online
online drugstore
prescription drug cost
Thanks a lot! I like it.
https://nicktambone.com/
online pharmacies no prescription global pharmacy canada canada pharmacies without script canada pharmaceutical online ordering
canada drug
us pharmacy no prior prescription
canada online pharmacy
no prescription pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
no prescription pharmacy
Many thanks, Terrific stuff.
http://talahicc.com/
discount prescription drug canadian pharmacies that ship to us prescription cost comparison canadian pharmacies that ship to us
drugs without prescription
canadian drugstore
my canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription
canadian prescription drugs
mexican pharmacy online
Nicely put. Regards!
http://talahicc.com/
best online pharmacy canadian drugs canadian pharmacy viagra top rated canadian pharmacies online
online canadian discount pharmacy
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
canadianpharmacy
mexican pharmacies
discount drugs online pharmacy
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
Thanks! Great stuff.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
top rated online canadian pharmacies mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canadian family pharmacy canada online pharmacies
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian drugs without prescription
online pharmacy no prescription
buy prescription drugs without doctor
online drugs
24 hour pharmacy
You made your stand quite effectively!!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacies that ship to us canada drug buy prescription drugs without doctor canadian pharmaceuticals online
drug stores near me
buy prescription drugs without doctor
prescription drugs online without doctor
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
no prescription online pharmacy
canada pharmacies online
Nicely put, Many thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian pharma companies aarp approved canadian online pharmacies pharmacy without dr prescriptions trust pharmacy canada
canada drug
best price prescription drugs
best canadian online pharmacy
pharmacy price comparison
canadian pharmacies
online discount pharmacy
You reported that superbly.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
walgreens pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online online pharmacies canada canadian pharmaceuticals online
prescription drugs prices
ed meds online
prescription drug assistance
prescription drugs online without
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy king
Many thanks! Plenty of info.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian prescriptions canadianpharmacy overseas pharmacies canadian pharmacies that ship to us
discount prescription drugs online
prescription price comparison
discount drugs online pharmacy
canadian prescription drugs
prescription drug price comparison
canada online pharmacy
Incredible loads of amazing knowledge.
https://nicktambone.com/
safe canadian online pharmacies canada pharmacy canadian pharma companies canadian pharmacy online
canadian prescription drugs
pharmacy tech
online drugs
prescription drug
buy drugs online
canada drugs online
Perfectly voiced genuinely. .
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
costco pharmacy pricing trust pharmacy canada buy cialis mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
international pharmacy
online canadian pharmacies
canada meds
canadian mail order pharmacies
canada drugs online pharmacy
no prescription pharmacies
Wonderful tips. Thanks!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
online discount pharmacy online pharmacies of canada pharmacy price compare canada drug
online pharmacy
buy cialis
prescription cost comparison
pharmacy online store
buy online prescription drugs
online canadian pharmacies
Thank you! Very good stuff!
http://talahicc.com/
best online pharmacy canadian pharmacies meds online canadian pharmacies that ship to us
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canadian pharmacy without prescription
cheap prescription drugs online
canadian pharmacy no prescription
pharmacy prices compare
no prior prescription required pharmacy
Whoa a good deal of fantastic data!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canada pharmacies online canadian pharmacies online candrugstore com canadian online pharmacy
drugs from canada
online discount pharmacy
us pharmacy no prior prescription
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
canadian prescription
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
Wow a lot of very good facts!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
medical information online canadian pharmacies-24h prescription drug cost london drugs canada
canadian pharmacy no prescription
prescription drug assistance
prescription online
canada pharmacy no prescription
mexican online pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
Kudos! Ample content.
http://talahicc.com/
discount pharmacy online north west pharmacy canada pharmacy prescription canadian drugs
online pharmacy no prescription needed
online pharmacy reviews
drugstore online
best online pharmacies no prescription
canadian discount pharmacy
legitimate online pharmacies
You actually said it perfectly!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharcharmy online northwestpharmacy buy prescription drugs without doctor canada pharmaceutical online ordering
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
rx pharmacy
prescription drugs without prior prescription
canada pharmacy no prescription
online pharmacy
pharmacy cost comparison
Fantastic data. Cheers.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian drugstore canadian online pharmacy
prescription pricing
mail order pharmacy
canada pharmacy online
medication costs
canada pharmacy online no script
online pharmacy reviews
Thanks, Quite a lot of postings!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
buy prescription drugs canada canada pharmacy canadian viagra canadian drugs
buy prescription drugs canada
canadian drugstore reviews
discount pharmacy online
cheap prescription drugs online
prescription price comparison
canada pharmacy online reviews
You have made your point!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian drug stores online canadianpharmacy meds online canadian pharmacies that ship to us
overseas pharmacy forum
canadian drugs
canada drugs online
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
24 hour pharmacy
drugs online
Very well voiced truly! !
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
best canadian online pharmacy canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacy king online pharmacies canada
mail order pharmacies
drugs from canada
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
buy drugs online
canadian drug
Very good data. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacies without an rx best online canadian pharcharmy canadian viagra
canada drugs online
prescription cost
canada pharmacy online no script
medical information online
buy online prescription drugs
canadian prescription
Regards, Fantastic stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian pharmacies that ship to us north west pharmacy canada buy prescription drugs canada global pharmacy canada
drug price
canadian pharcharmy online
best canadian online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies top best
cheap prescription drugs online
online pharmacy no prescription needed
You actually revealed that wonderfully.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
price prescription drugs canada pharmaceutical online ordering safe canadian online pharmacies canada pharmaceutical online ordering
prescription drugs online without
best online international pharmacies
drug prices comparison
discount pharmacy online
online drugstore
board of pharmacy
Amazing data, Cheers!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
medical information online canadian drugs no 1 canadian pharcharmy online canadian viagra
international pharmacy
top rated online canadian pharmacies
prescription drug price comparison
canada pharmacy online reviews
no prescription pharmacies
canadian prescription drugstore
Cheers! Lots of knowledge!
https://nicktambone.com/
rx online online pharmacies of canada visit poster’s website canadian drugs
best online pharmacy stores
online pharmacy
online canadian discount pharmacy
24 hour pharmacy
canada drugs online pharmacy
cialis canadian pharmacy
Thanks a lot! An abundance of info!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
ed meds online canada drugs canadian pharmacies shipping to usa canada online pharmacies
cialis canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy online no script
pharmacy prices
buying prescription drugs canada
canadapharmacyonline com
cheap prescription drugs
Amazing a good deal of superb information.
http://talahicc.com/
canada pharmacies without script canadian viagra discount prescription drugs online canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy no prescription
best online pharmacy
approved canadian pharmacies online
canadian rx pharmacy online
get prescription online
prescription cost comparison
You have made your point!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacy cost comparison canadian pharcharmy canadian pharmacy viagra aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canada drugs pharmacy
the canadian pharmacy
best non prescription online pharmacies
online pharmacy
best online pharmacies no prescription
visit poster’s website
Nicely put, Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
cialis canadian pharmacy northwestpharmacy northwest pharmacy canada canadian pharcharmy
safeway pharmacy
drug stores near me
best canadian online pharmacy
canadianpharmacy
prescription drug cost
pharmacy near me
Cheers, A lot of advice!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
mail order pharmacy canadianpharmacy canadian viagra canadian pharmacies online
prescription cost
overseas pharmacy forum
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian viagra
prescription drugs canada
canadian online pharmacy reviews
Regards! Plenty of data!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
get prescription online top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacy reviews canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy reviews
pharmacy price compare
pain meds online without doctor prescription
canadian drugstore online
canadapharmacyonline com
cheap prescription drugs online
Good material, Regards.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
visit poster’s website canadian pharmacies without an rx discount pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online
pharmacy online mexico
cheap prescription drugs online
canadian pharmacies online prescriptions
medication costs
no prior prescription required pharmacy
buy drugs online
Many thanks! An abundance of write ups.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadapharmacy com canadian pharmacies medication costs canada drug
drugs without prescription
drugs for sale
canadian drugstore
king pharmacy
canada pharmacies prescription drugs
24 hour pharmacy
You have made your point!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada online pharmacy canadian online pharmacies approved canadian pharmacies online canadian online pharmacies
online pharmacy without a prescription
canadian prescription drugs
buy prescription drugs canada
online pharmacy without prescription
prescription drug assistance
meds online